Indifferents In Stoicism Explained Through Gain, Loss, Pleasure & Pain

Indifferents In Stoicism Explained Through Gain, Loss, Pleasure & Pain

In the pivotal Game 5 of the 1997 NBA Finals, Michael Jordan battled a severe flu, yet soared to iconic heights. Against the surging Utah Jazz, he defied physical limits, sinking clutch shots and leading the Chicago Bulls to a crucial victory. His resilience showcased the essence of a true basketball legend, etching the “Flu Game” into sporting history. Would Jordan have preferred to be healthy for that game? Of course. But he treated his symptoms with indifference. Most importantly, he showed up—he acted in accordance with his values. He played the game with skill despite battling dispreferred indifferents. In this article, we’ll unpack the concept indifferents in Stoicism. Once we get past the somewhat paradoxical feel of terms like “preferred indifferents” and “dispreferred indifferents”, you’ll find that the Stoic concept of indifferents is simple and immensely useful for navigating the ups and downs of life.

 

“We have the potential for it [to live a good life]. If we can learn to be indifferent to what makes no difference.” – Marcus Aurelius, Meditations (paid link)

 

Related article: How To Practice Stoicism: An Introduction & 12 Stoic Practices

 

What are the indifferents of Stoicism? 

 

In Stoicism, “indifferents” are external circumstances, possessions, and events that are neither inherently good nor bad, because the only things that can be inherently good or bad are virtue and character. To practicing Stoics, the only thing that is not to be treated with indifference is your moral character. 

 

If Michael Jordan had played that Game 5 despite a crushing flu, led his team with heroic play to a lead late in the game, but then had somehow cheated in the dying seconds, it would all be for nothing. His resilience would have been forgotten. Only his misdemeanor would have remained on record. 

 

One of the reasons Stoicism endures as a popular philosophy today is its practicality. The founding Stoics realized that it’s unrealistic to not have preferences. Of course, we play the game to win, but we do not cheat, turn a blind eye to suffering that we could prevent, or engage in obsessive desire. This is why the Stoics developed the concepts of “preferred indifferents” and “dispreferred indifferents”.

 

“There is great difference between joy and pain; if I am asked to choose, I shall seek the former and avoid the latter. The former is according to nature, the latter is contrary to it. So long as they are rated by this standard, there is a great gulf between; but when it comes to a question of the virtue involved, the virtue in each case is the same, whether it comes through joy or through sorrow.” – Seneca

This post contains affiliate links, which help us keep the blog afloat. Click here for more information.

The silhouette of an archer taking aim at dusk to represent an article about indifferents in Stoicism

Preferred indifferents 

 

Preferred indifferents in Stoicism refer to things which are considered indifferent in themselves but are preferred because they can contribute to a virtuous life. You can be healthy, fit, and bursting with energy, but if you got that way by spending twenty hours a week at the gym while your partner is at home struggling to keep up with the kids, then you are of poor character—you were ignorant of the concept of “preferred indifferents”. Conversely, if you are healthy because you take care of yourself moderately and fulfill your primary duties in life, then health is a benefit which supports your ability to live virtuously. The Stoics used this label of preferred indifferent not as a paradox. They used it to remind us that it’s natural to prefer health over illness, but even health cannot come at the expense of good character. 

 

Indifferent to gain

 

There are endless ways to become wealthy in exchange for one’s character. Of course, it’s better to have money than to not have it. Poverty is a health risk. But the Stoics would deplore the young man who sets the standard for weakness in his neighborhood by selling drugs—becoming a poor role model for all the younger eyes observing him. Similarly, the businessperson who exchanges a few hundred extra tons of CO2 emissions to cut expenses is no Stoic. 

The pursuit of balance podcast year end sale, save 60%

Indifferent to pleasure

 

Sex is probably the ultimate preferred indifferent. It can be the source of intimacy, passion, and ecstasy in a mutual loving relationship. But it can also drive people to their worst. It’s the impetus for frustration, infidelity, and, tragically, human trafficking. The ancient Stoics would encourage you to have good sex, and often, as long as it didn’t curtail your virtues.

 

Dispreferred indifferents 

 

Dispreferred indifferents in Stoicism refer to circumstances, such as poverty or illness, which are considered indifferent in themselves but are dispreferred because they can pose challenges to living a virtuous life. The Stoics were wise to acknowledge that some things in life are best avoided. Aversion responses are encoded in our DNA. We wouldn’t have come far as a species if we didn’t learn to avoid predators, poisons, and dangerous people. 

The silhouette of an archer taking aim at a target at dusk to represent an article about indifferents in Stoicism

Indifferent to loss 

 

Most wealthy people are not stress free. They don’t need to worry about the bills or whether they’ll be able to afford gifts for special occasions. But they do worry about losing those capabilities. They worry about mutual fund management fees and stock prices. They worry about transferring their wealth to the next generation. These worries are dispreferred indifferents. But if the desire to grasp onto one’s wealth prevents them from living virtuously—living for the betterment of the world around them—then they exceed the realm of indifferents and become a problem. 

 

Much excessive grasping and aversion stems from failure to recognize the impermanent nature of everything, as Epictetus reminds us: 

 

“What if things, objects, and beings that delight your mind are of good practical use, or which you dearly love? Remind yourself of their true nature, beginning with the smallest trifle and working upward. If you have a favorite cup, remember that it is only a cup that you prefer. If it is broken, you can bear it. When you embrace your wife or child, remember that they are mortal beings. By accepting their nature, rather than denying it, if either should die you will find the strength to bear it.”

 

Personally, I have a hard time with this sharp turn from losing one’s favorite cup to losing one’s child. As a new father, it doesn’t sit well. But I can see the wisdom in accepting rather than denying. If the unthinkable happened, and a person lost their child, and still had the will to live, they would need acceptance, character, and virtue to keep on going. These would be the branches stretching out over the raging river of sorrow. And everything else would be indifferent.

 

“Do not say of anything ‘I have lost it,’ but rather ‘I have given it back.’ Has your wife died? You have given her back. Has your child died? You have given him back. Have you lost your home? You have given it back. ‘But…,’ you may retort, a bad person took it. It is not your concern by what means something returns to the source from which it came, for as long as the source entrusts something to your hands, treat it as something borrowed, like a traveler at an inn.” – Epictetus, The Manual (paid link)

watch the pursuit of balance podcast now

Indifferent to pain

 

When I was young, my mother was in a car accident. Ever since the accident, she has suffered from a chronic pain disorder called fibromyalgia. Growing up, though, I would never have known that she was in near constant pain. She didn’t show it. Instead, she showed up as a mother. My parents divorced when I was ten, so she raised me single handedly from then on and through my (quite) troubled teen years. She’s also one of the most compassionate people I know. Last winter, she spent hours knitting hats and scarves to donate to local homeless shelters. Just the other day she told me how she gave away her late father’s power tools to a man she knows who needed them. 

 

She’s a Stoic—whether she knows it or not. Despite a severe dispreferred indifferent in the form of a chronic health disorder, she lives virtuously. She strives (and succeeds) to do good.

 

It’s how we choose to respond to pain that matters. We must reach into our toolkits, pull out fortitude or resilience, and decide to use those tools to help us maintain virtue despite pain. This is how Stoics respond to dispreferred indifferents. 

 

“Whenever a challenge arises, turn inward and ask what power you can exercise in this situation. If you meet temptation, use self-control. If you meet pain, use fortitude. If you meet revulsion, use patience. In this way, you will overcome life’s challenges rather than be overcome by them.” – Epictetus, The Manual (paid link)

 

Final thoughts 

 

I was inspired to lead this article with the Michael Jordan anecdote, because it was Socrates, who was a major influence on early Stoicism, who said that we must play the game of life with skill, but treat the ball with indifference. Don’t be confused by the seemingly paradoxical ring to terms like preferred and dispreferred indifferents. The message is simple: know your highest values—your purpose and virtues—and know them well because nothing is more important. If you uphold your virtues and pleasure and gain come your way, then all the better. If you maintain a strong and compassionate character despite bad things happening to you, then all the better.

Introduction To Stoicism And Mindfulness

If you're new to mindfulness or Stoicism, we hope you'll find these articles written as introductory resources useful. We aim to answer questions like "What is mindfulness?" and "How can I begin practicing Stoicism?" We hope something here will set you off on your...

Improve Your Focus With Mindfulness- And Science-Based Protocols

I’ve said this before, but I feel it’s important to lead with it here: mindfulness is not a means to an end. Mindfulness is a means to a means—a way of waking up to life. Without mindfulness, so much of life escapes us. Without mindfulness, we’re governed by impulses...

Where Buddhism And Modern Psychology Converge On Mental Wellness

When the average non-Buddhist westerner thinks of Buddhism, they often think of meditation, kindness, and monks with shaved heads in orange robes. But what lies beneath these surface-level artifacts is profound understanding. Few wisdom traditions have delivered as...

Karma In Buddhism: Sowing The Seeds Of Love

In modern times, we use the word karma in many ways. ‘Ain’t karma a bitch’—meaning what ‘Goes around, comes around.’ It can also refer to the Golden Rule from the Hebrew and Christian Bible: ‘Do unto others what as you would have them do unto you.’ But, in the context...

What The Death Of Marcus Aurelius Teaches Us About Life

Marcus Aurelius died in a cold, dark place, but his last words shined bright with a message of hope: “Go to the rising sun, for I am already setting.” He delivered these words not to a beloved, but to a guard of the night’s watch in his military camp near the...

Zen Meditation: How To Stop And Reflect For Wisdom 

  What if there was a way you could train your wisdom and insight? No tools or equipment required. No books to read. No classes to attend. All you’d need is a few minutes each day. Such a means of building a wider perspective and developing clear insight exists....

Right Mindfulness & Right Concentration Of The Eightfold Path

If I were to define Zen Buddhism, I would do so in two four-word sentences:   Absolute attention is prayer. Compassion for all beings.   “Zen teaches nothing. It merely enables us to wake up and become aware. It does not teach; it points. The truth of Zen is...

The Three Jewels Of The Tao: Embracing The Way Of Water

Well, the first challenge in understanding the Tao is its definition. Translated literally, 'The Tao' means 'The Way'. The very first verse of this ancient teaching warns that it’s useless to try to define or name The Tao: The Tao that can be toldIs not the eternal...

21 Human Performance Tips For Busy People

To say my life is busy is an understatement. Writing this blog is my passion. I wouldn’t trade it for the world. But writing the blog, two weekly newsletters, and a book is a tall order. There is no team, there are no editors, web developers, graphic designers, or...

Thich Nhat Hanh & The Zen Practice Of Stopping

Thich Nhat Hanh was a Vietnamese Zen Buddhist monk, peace activist, prolific author, poet and teacher, historically known as the ‘father of mindfulness’. Nhat Hanh was a major influence on Western practices of Buddhism.   He was exiled from South Vietnam in 1966 after...

The best books on Stoicism

Explore our curated collection of the top-rated and latest books on Stoicism.

Memorialize your commitment

Explore our collection of Stoic coins and other apparel.

Memento Mori: Embracing Life’s Impermanence In The Digital Age

Memento Mori: Embracing Life’s Impermanence In The Digital Age

In the age of smartphones, social media, and endless distractions, the ancient Stoic concept of Memento Mori has never been more relevant. Loosely translated as “Remember that you must die,” Memento Mori serves as a powerful reminder of our mortality and the fleeting nature of life. Let’s explore this timeliness concept and discover how it can help us navigate the digital age and find meaning in the midst of constant connectivity.

 

What does Memento Mori mean?

 

Memento Mori is a Latin phrase that translates to “Remember your mortality.” It’s a philosophical concept that serves as a reminder of our mortality, urging us to acknowledge the impermanence of life and to live with a sense of purpose and mindfulness in the face of this inevitable reality.

 

Memento Mori is not meant to be a morbid exercise. Rather, it’s meant to spark enthusiasm for life itself. ‘Remember’ is the operative word here, because we all know on an intellectual level that our time is limited. It’s just that we tend to forget, which leads us to squander our time.

 

This practice is not unique to Stoicism. In Buddhism, the concept of impermanence is central to most teachings. There are even Buddhist meditative practices whereby the meditator visualizes their decaying body, eventually imagining it turning to dust. 

 

In his book The Miracle of Mindfulness, the late Zen Buddhist monk, Thich Nhat Hanh, describes his newfound insight after having initially resisted the practice of visualizing death and coming to terms with it:

 

“Now I see that if one doesn’t know how to die, one can hardly see how to live—because death is a part of life.”

This post contains affiliate links, which help us keep the blog afloat. Click here for more information.

A close up of an hour glass with white sand over a black background to represent an article on the Stoic practice of Memento Mori

Memento Mori resolves the digital dilemma

 

In today’s world, we’re bombarded with a constant stream of information and entertainment. Our smartphones keep us plugged into the digital realm 24/7, making it easy to forget about our own mortality. We’re so engrossed in virtual lives that the idea of death often remains distant and abstract.

 

Yet, it’s precisely in this digital age that the Stoic concept of Memento Mori can offer us profound wisdom. By reflecting on the impermanence of life, we can gain a unique perspective on our relationship with technology and its impact on our well-being.

 

With the age of fully immersive, AI- and VR-powered meta universes just around the corner, it is perhaps practices like mindfulness and Memento Mori that will preserve what it even means and feels like to be human.

 

The endless scroll vs. the finite lifespan

 

Imagine scrolling through your social media feed endlessly, consumed by an infinite stream of content. Now, contrast that with the Stoic reminder that your own life is finite. Memento Mori prompts us to question how we spend our precious time. Are we investing it wisely in meaningful pursuits, or are we frittering it away on trivial distractions?

 

Take stock of how you spend your time. It is the most precious, non-renewable resource you have, so think twice about mindless digital consumption. 

Related article: Memento Vivere: How To Live With Agency, Gratitude & Engagement

The pursuit of balance podcast year end sale, save 60%

Digital detox: A modern Memento Mori practice

 

In the digital age, taking a break from our screens and devices can be a form of Memento Mori practice in itself. Consider a digital detox as a reminder of the physical world around us. Unplugging and spending time in nature, engaging in face-to-face conversations, or simply meditating on our own mortality can help us restore balance in a hyperconnected world.

 

Here are four practical tips on how to do an effective digital detox: 

 

  • Set clear boundaries: Start by defining specific time periods or situations where you’ll disconnect from digital devices. This could be during meals, before bedtime, or on weekends. Communicate these boundaries to friends and family to get their support.

 

  • Turn off notifications: Disable non-essential app notifications to reduce the constant urge to check your phone. This will help you regain control over your attention and reduce distractions.

  • Engage in offline activities: Plan activities that don’t involve screens, such as reading physical books, taking nature walks, practicing a hobby, or spending quality time with loved ones. These activities will help you rediscover the joy of the offline world.

  • Reflect and reevaluate: During your digital detox, take time to reflect on how it’s impacting your well-being. Journal your thoughts and feelings, noting any positive changes in your mood, productivity, or relationships. Use this feedback to make necessary adjustments and incorporate healthier tech habits into your daily life.

 

Legacy in the digital realm

 

In an era where our digital footprints often outlive us, Memento Mori encourages us to consider the legacy we leave online. What do our social media profiles say about us? How will our digital presence be remembered when we’re gone? This reflection can inspire us to curate our online lives with more intention, authenticity, and compassion.

A dark close up of an hour glass over a black background to represent an article on the Stoic practice of Memento Mori

Mindful living and digital minimalism

 

Memento Mori invites us to live with mindfulness, appreciating each moment as it comes. In a world ringing and buzzing with notifications and constant updates, practicing digital minimalism can help us reclaim our time and focus on what truly matters.

 

Mindfulness is a central theme of this blog because it’s the most effective means of connecting with life. It’s like a spotlight of attention, illuminating whatever we choose to shine it on. It not only allows us to experience life, rather than being distracted from it, but it’s also a precursor to philosophical practices such as Stoicism. Without mindful awareness, it’s impossible to respond (as opposed to react) to difficult situations virtuously. 

 

Related article: Mindfulness And Distraction: The Gardener Removes The Weeds

watch the pursuit of balance podcast now

Final thoughts

 

Memento Mori isn’t just a philosophical concept from times of Roman imperial glory; it’s a timely and powerful reminder for our digital age. By embracing our own impermanence, we can cultivate a deeper sense of meaning and purpose in a world filled with distractions. So the next time you reach for your smartphone, remember the words of the Stoics:

 

“Life, if well lived, is long enough.”

– Seneca

 

“You could leave life right now. Let that determine what you do and say and think.”

– Marcus Aurelius

 

Embrace life’s impermanence, and let it guide you to a more mindful and intentional existence in the digital era.

Introduction To Stoicism And Mindfulness

If you're new to mindfulness or Stoicism, we hope you'll find these articles written as introductory resources useful. We aim to answer questions like "What is mindfulness?" and "How can I begin practicing Stoicism?" We hope something here will set you off on your...

Improve Your Focus With Mindfulness- And Science-Based Protocols

I’ve said this before, but I feel it’s important to lead with it here: mindfulness is not a means to an end. Mindfulness is a means to a means—a way of waking up to life. Without mindfulness, so much of life escapes us. Without mindfulness, we’re governed by impulses...

Where Buddhism And Modern Psychology Converge On Mental Wellness

When the average non-Buddhist westerner thinks of Buddhism, they often think of meditation, kindness, and monks with shaved heads in orange robes. But what lies beneath these surface-level artifacts is profound understanding. Few wisdom traditions have delivered as...

Karma In Buddhism: Sowing The Seeds Of Love

In modern times, we use the word karma in many ways. ‘Ain’t karma a bitch’—meaning what ‘Goes around, comes around.’ It can also refer to the Golden Rule from the Hebrew and Christian Bible: ‘Do unto others what as you would have them do unto you.’ But, in the context...

What The Death Of Marcus Aurelius Teaches Us About Life

Marcus Aurelius died in a cold, dark place, but his last words shined bright with a message of hope: “Go to the rising sun, for I am already setting.” He delivered these words not to a beloved, but to a guard of the night’s watch in his military camp near the...

Zen Meditation: How To Stop And Reflect For Wisdom 

  What if there was a way you could train your wisdom and insight? No tools or equipment required. No books to read. No classes to attend. All you’d need is a few minutes each day. Such a means of building a wider perspective and developing clear insight exists....

Right Mindfulness & Right Concentration Of The Eightfold Path

If I were to define Zen Buddhism, I would do so in two four-word sentences:   Absolute attention is prayer. Compassion for all beings.   “Zen teaches nothing. It merely enables us to wake up and become aware. It does not teach; it points. The truth of Zen is...

The Three Jewels Of The Tao: Embracing The Way Of Water

Well, the first challenge in understanding the Tao is its definition. Translated literally, 'The Tao' means 'The Way'. The very first verse of this ancient teaching warns that it’s useless to try to define or name The Tao: The Tao that can be toldIs not the eternal...

21 Human Performance Tips For Busy People

To say my life is busy is an understatement. Writing this blog is my passion. I wouldn’t trade it for the world. But writing the blog, two weekly newsletters, and a book is a tall order. There is no team, there are no editors, web developers, graphic designers, or...

Thich Nhat Hanh & The Zen Practice Of Stopping

Thich Nhat Hanh was a Vietnamese Zen Buddhist monk, peace activist, prolific author, poet and teacher, historically known as the ‘father of mindfulness’. Nhat Hanh was a major influence on Western practices of Buddhism.   He was exiled from South Vietnam in 1966 after...

The best books on Stoicism

Explore our curated collection of the top-rated and latest books on Stoicism.

Memorialize your commitment

Explore our collection of Stoic coins and other apparel.

The Stoic Concept Of Summum Bonum: The Stoic North Star

The Stoic Concept Of Summum Bonum: The Stoic North Star

There can only be one priority. If you think about it, the plural of the word priority is nonsensical. Priority means the most important thing. There can’t be two most important things. Having a sole priority is useful in business, but it’s also indispensable for living a balanced life. In Stoicism, the priority is known by a Latin maxim; Summum bonum, which translates to ‘the highest good’. Summum bonum is like the ultimate goal—the predominant purpose behind all other actions, plans, and projects. In this article, we’ll explore the concept of Summum bonum in Stoicism and how it guides us towards living with virtue and reason. More generally, we’ll discuss a concept that I call ‘The North Star’, which is simply the practice of defining and being constantly aware of your only priority in life. 

 

What is Summum bonum? 

 

Summum bonum refers to the highest good, the ultimate purpose or goal that practicing Stoics commit to uphold. For the ancient Stoics, this elemental good is synonymous with eudaimonia, a state of flourishing and well-being that arises from living virtuously and in harmony with nature. Eudaimonia isn’t just fleeting happiness. It encompasses a deeper sense of contentment derived from moral excellence and self-mastery.

 

From my reading of Stoicism, I’ve gathered that ultimately, we strive for Summum bonum and eudaimonia in order to make the world a better place. Let’s break down the definition of Summum bonum for a moment to illustrate this point. From the above definition, we can extract concepts like ‘living virtuously’ and ‘in harmony with nature’. 

 

But what use is virtue if not in relation to other people, animals, and ultimately the beautiful planet we all share? What nature are we trying to harmonize with? Sure, the ancient Stoics had their metaphysical perspectives on the meaning of ‘nature’. But to us in the twenty-first century, surely living in harmony with nature involves a world without needless suffering. As social beings, we cannot truly flourish nor have well-being without interdependent relationships with others. To take this train of thought to its extreme, Stoicism would be of very little use if you lived alone on a lifeless planet. 

This post contains affiliate links, which help us keep the blog afloat. Click here for more information.

A photo of a red rose to represent an article about the Stoic concept of summum bonum

Why is the concept of Summum bonum useful? 

Stoicism gives us several fantastic, two-word maxims: amor fati, memento mori, premeditatio malorum, and summum bonum. Their ultimate utility is their brevity. They’re short, concise, but most importantly, they’re easy to remember. They’re like mental bookmarks that help us flip to a certain chapter of Stoic wisdom quickly. They serve as signposts, which are simple at face value but denote something much more significant. The significance of the maxim Summum bonum is a reminder to act virtuously and do your part, no matter how small, to reduce suffering in the world. We read about Stoicism, then we adapt the wisdom to our own lives through meditation and journaling. Then, in practice, we can use maxims like Summum bonum to remind ourselves of our intentions as we navigate through the real world.

“Just that you do the right thing. The rest doesn’t matter. Cold or warm. Tired or well-rested. Despised or honored. Dying… or busy with other assignments.”

– Marcus Aurelius, Meditations

The pursuit of balance podcast year end sale, save 60%

Know your North Star 

 

The North Star has been a guiding light for humans for millennia. It has the power to show us the way when we’d otherwise be lost. But it only has this guiding power because it is singular and recognizable. If there were two, three, or four identical north stars in the night sky, we would be unable to distinguish between them. They would be useless for navigation. 

 

The same applies to our priorities in life. If there are several, they become indistinguishable. When this happens, we are unable to give the top priority what it deserves: singularity of focus or at least majority of focus. So you must do your best to quantify but ultimately answer the question: ‘what is my singular purpose, my ultimate priority—my north star?

 

Having a singular purpose does profound things. It promotes intrinsic motivation, which is the kind of motivation that comes from within you rather than from external sources such as economic pressure. Intrinsic motivation is the most sustainable form of motivation because it is truly aligned with your values. 

 

Having a north star also improves focus. When you have a precise definition of your only priority, you can place competing matters of lesser importance into other, smaller time slots for you to work on. 

 

Knowing your north star also guides your decisions. When faced with a question or dilemma, you can ask yourself, ‘does this promote or hinder my ultimate purpose?

An image of a red rose to represent an article about the Stoic concept of summum bonum

Summum bonum: The Stoic North Star

 

My idea of The North Star should be personalized for each person’s unique circumstances. Only you can block out the time to reflect on and eventually decide on your north star—your singular priority in life. But Stoicism and its concept of Summum bonum can help shape your north star. Here’s how:

 

Summum bonum means the highest good. It means living virtuously and in harmony with nature. With nature and virtue being codependent and interconnected with the well-being of all other living beings on this planet, then the rational conclusion is that we should all strive to reduce suffering and optimize for health, happiness, and creative expression in ourselves and others. Therefore, as a practitioner of Stoicism, your north star or singular priority should align with these goals. 

 

Related article: Interconnection & Its Connection With Stoicism

 

By the way, Buddhism has the exact same pinnacle aim; reducing the suffering of others. Buddhism has wonderful, practical guiding principles for our actions, such as The Eightfold Path, but they’re not just for fun. An immense amount of thought and refinement has gone into these wisdom teachings for one clear reason; again, to reduce the suffering of others. 

watch the pursuit of balance podcast now

How to practice Summum bonum 

 

Summum bonum itself is not really a practice. As mentioned above, it’s more of a reminder to practice and why. The ‘why’ is the highest good or your own north star. If it’s helpful to you, you can use the words Summum bonum or any other short phrase to help keep your singular purpose at arm’s length. Then, as practitioners of Stoicism, we can rely on other Stoic practices to help us optimize for that purpose.

 

Practices such as negative visualization (premeditatio malorum), journaling, and mindfulness help us develop self-awareness, gratitude, and a deeper understanding of our reactions to external events.

 

Related article: Premeditatio Malorum: A Practice For Resilience

 

Another powerful Stoic practice is The Dichotomy of Control, which divides external events into two categories: things that are within our control and things that are not. Summum Bonum lies within the realm of internal factors—our attitudes, beliefs, and actions—over which we have direct control. 

 

Final thoughts on Summum bonum

 

Summum bonum means highest good, not merely a high good—not just one of many. There can only be one highest good. There can only be one priority. This can be counterintuitive, because society is very good at shoveling commitments and obligations at us. 

 

I’m not saying that your to-do list can only hold one item. Of course, your projects, plans, and even personal and familial commitments will require some prioritization. There will be multiple things to work on and you will need to rank order them and do them chronologically, of course. But I believe that having a singular priority that defines the way you want to live brings clarity and equanimity to your life. When you know what is most important in your life, you will be less likely to accept plans and projects that don’t align with it. You’ll be more motivated. You’ll be more decisive. 

 

If we look to wisdom traditions such as Stoicism or Buddhism for guidance, we’re led to a beautiful conclusion: that singular purpose, sole priority, north star, or whatever you want to call it, should be in some way for the betterment of the world we live in. 

Debunking 8 Common Misconceptions About Stoicism: What It Really Means To Be A Stoic

I blame the English dictionary for a good chunk of the misconceptions about Stoicism. Look up the word ‘stoic’ there and you’ll find something like, “a person who can endure pain or hardship without showing their feelings or complaining.” Or maybe it’s the wealth of...

The Three Stoic Disciplines: Desire, Action, and Assent

Stoicism is a guiding framework in my life, but so is business. I can think of no better school of thought than business when it comes to manifesting ideas into reality—big, complex ideas. Schools of business and businesses in practice are fountains of knowledge when...

Improve Your Focus With Mindfulness- And Science-Based Protocols

I’ve said this before, but I feel it’s important to lead with it here: mindfulness is not a means to an end. Mindfulness is a means to a means—a way of waking up to life. Without mindfulness, so much of life escapes us. Without mindfulness, we’re governed by impulses...

What Is Modern Stoicism? An Introduction & Essential Practices

In the eyes of some, the people I’m about to introduce don’t belong in a discussion about modern Stoicism. None of them are self-proclaimed Stoics. But they do display extreme commitment to the four Stoic virtues: courage, temperance, wisdom, and justice.   ...

Where Buddhism And Modern Psychology Converge On Mental Wellness

When the average non-Buddhist westerner thinks of Buddhism, they often think of meditation, kindness, and monks with shaved heads in orange robes. But what lies beneath these surface-level artifacts is profound understanding. Few wisdom traditions have delivered as...

How To Speak Like A Stoic

If you’ve mastered the art of peaceful speech, then it is likely that you have a very firm grasp over your guiding principles. If you have mastered the art of the pause in speech, then it is likely that you have clear convictions and great self-confidence. Truthful,...

What The Death Of Marcus Aurelius Teaches Us About Life

Marcus Aurelius died in a cold, dark place, but his last words shined bright with a message of hope: “Go to the rising sun, for I am already setting.” He delivered these words not to a beloved, but to a guard of the night’s watch in his military camp near the...

Zen Meditation: How To Stop And Reflect For Wisdom 

  What if there was a way you could train your wisdom and insight? No tools or equipment required. No books to read. No classes to attend. All you’d need is a few minutes each day. Such a means of building a wider perspective and developing clear insight exists....

Memento Vivere: How To Live With Agency, Gratitude & Engagement

Antipater is a lesser-known Stoic, yet he was head of the school during a period that saw Stoicism extend to public life. Stoic philosophers were sent on diplomatic missions. Some advised kings. But Antipater’s contributions brought Stoicism closer to home. He was...

Right Mindfulness & Right Concentration Of The Eightfold Path

If I were to define Zen Buddhism, I would do so in two four-word sentences:   Absolute attention is prayer. Compassion for all beings.   “Zen teaches nothing. It merely enables us to wake up and become aware. It does not teach; it points. The truth of Zen is...

Amor Fati Explained: Turning Life’s Trials Into Triumphs

Amor Fati Explained: Turning Life’s Trials Into Triumphs

The meaning of amor fati is nestled inside this short story: There was an old farmer who had a herd of horses. One day, the horses broke through the fence and the whole herd ran off into the wild. 

On hearing the unfortunate news, the old farmer’s neighbor came over and said, ‘This is really bad fortune for you.’ The old farmer simply replied, ‘Maybe.’

 

The next day, to everyone’s surprise, the herd returned but with a beautiful black stallion in their midst. This stallion was a valuable asset. 

 

Again, the neighbor came over and said to the old farmer, ‘This is very good fortune for you.’ The farmer simply rejoined with ‘Maybe’. 

 

The very next day, the farmer’s son tried to mount the new black stallion, fell, and broke his leg. 

 

Once again, the neighbor appeared. ‘This is very bad fortune for you.’ Again, the farmer simply sighed and said, ‘Maybe.’ 

 

A week passed and the army came to the farmer’s village to press all the young men into service. The captain of the army came up to the old farmer and demanded that he hand over his only son. 

 

Unfortunately, the farmer’s son was on crutches, nursing a badly broken leg and the army moved on to the next homestead.

 

The meaning of amor fati

 

This short story demonstrates some key components of the deeper meaning of amor fati. It shows that we must have the humility to acknowledge that we don’t really know if an outcome will be wholly good or bad. Causes almost always have unexpected effects. This is what makes life beautiful and interesting. 

 

The story also shows that we must remain anchored under the crashing waves of life, ever confident in our abilities to navigate any twist or turn with virtue and grace. In this article, I’ll attempt to provide a definition of amor fati and provide insights on how to practice amor fati in Stoicism. 

“When you come across a bad omen, like a black cat or a squawking raven, distinguish between reality and interpretation. Remind yourself, nothing is foreboding to me. All signs point to good luck if I interpret them that way. Whatever life brings, I can use it to my advantage.”

– Epictetus, The Manual 

 

What does amor fati mean?

Amor fati is more than just a Latin phrase that translates to ‘the love of fate’. In Stoicism, amor fati is a binding thread that ties together a few different teachings of Stoic philosophy. Without amor fati, you can’t master The Dichotomy of Control, which is ignoring what is not within your control so that you can focus fully on what is within your control. Without amor fati, you can’t leverage The Art of Acquiescence, which is the practice of accepting the bad so that you can move past it.

For practicing Stoics, amor fati is about so much more than just peak performance. Amor fati is a practice that unlocks the beauty, wonder, and adventure of life itself. It’s standing at the edge of the precipice, looking down, feeling the fear, but jumping anyway into the cool blue water far below and reaping the reward of exhilaration. 

We love to think that we’re in control. But, we’re not. Nature dictates everything that happens in your life. 

The ancient Stoics knew this. Stoicism is based on the idea that we must act in accordance with and not against the grain of nature. When we do this—when we practice amor fati by embracing anything and everything that life conjures up—we begin to live truly. 

How can we fully enjoy this life in all its rarity and brevity if we’re constantly attempting to manipulate every outcome? How will we ever be surprised or have serendipitous encounters if we’re locked inside a cage of calendars, schedules, and routines?

Related article: Memento Vivere: How To Live With Agency, Gratitude & Engagement

This post contains affiliate links, which help us keep the blog afloat. Click here for more information.

A woman doing a yoga pose on the beach looking out at strong ocean waves to represent an article about amor fati in stoicism

Amor fati is a balance between receptivity and control

In Stoicism, amor fati must precede The Dichotomy of Control, because we need to wake up in the morning with receptivity. When that alarm clock goes off, you must say to yourself ‘I will cherish this day and all that it offers’. Only after we’ve done this, only after we’ve opened our minds and our hearts to receive what the day has planned for us (and not what we have planned for the day) can we then begin to implement plans and actions towards a desired outcome. 

This is the beauty of Stoicism. It acknowledges that despite nature’s ultimate command over us, we still need to get shit done, or at least try. In our plans and pursuits, we must underscore every step we take with the knowledge that nature is much more powerful than even the best ideas executed well. Nature can and will get in our way. 

The operative word in the phrase amor fati is love. It’s not a begrudging acceptance of fate, but a wholehearted embrace. We already know how to embrace the beauty that life offers us in its most recognizable forms, such as intimacy with those we love, the colors of the changing seasons, the night sky, or the vitality of good health. We also need to learn to love the aspects of life that we generally reject as unpleasant. 

The Stoics taught that we must embrace dark times because they test us. Without darkness, we wouldn’t even need a personal, fortifying philosophy such as Stoicism. 

The pursuit of balance podcast year end sale, save 60%

How to practice amor fati 

As I’ve already mentioned, amor fati is closely related to two other Stoic concepts: The Dichotomy of Control and The Art of Acquiescence. These two practices offer a practical approach to amor fati, so they are useful when you’re attempting to get things done in life. 

The Dichotomy of Control as a practice hones our ability to see what is not within our control. To master The Dichotomy of Control we must embrace the uncontrollable variables.

 

When you’re traveling, you may plan to arrive at the airport on time, but the taxi you called may be late to arrive. Then, at the airport, the lines may be much longer than you had expected. An argument may erupt between the check-in personnel and the passenger just in front of you in line. None of these factors are in your control. This means that you do not get upset. Even if you miss your flight, cursing the taxi driver and the asshole in front of you in line is a useless waste of energy. The Stoic approach would be to begin immediately looking for the next flight or altering your plans in some other way. 

The Art of Acquiescence, for its part, is an efficiency practice. It teaches us that the faster we come to terms with defeat, the quicker we can get back to our pursuit of victory. Any time or energy spent lamenting, blaming, or regretting is time or energy not spent on improving. We embrace obstacles so that we can break through or move around them. 

Related article: Master The Art Of Acquiescence For Resilience & Perspective

How else can we practice amor fati? 

The universe is not aligned with you 

To really incorporate a love of fate into your life, you must first understand that the universe doesn’t care about your plans or projects. You share this planet with billions of other humans, all of whom have their own plans and projects. You live on a planet governed by weather and the natural laws of physics. And everything changes constantly. To think that the universe will somehow accommodate your will is pure ignorance. 

But, this shouldn’t make you feel small. In fact, the opposite is true. We’re all interconnected. Although we all have different plans and projects, we all share the fact that we’re trying to live on this beautiful blue planet amid its natural cycles of change. We all gaze at the same stars. We all drink the same water. Your sadness, anger or despair are no different than anyone else’s. This should make you feel huge—included as part of a dynamic whole.  

Related article: Interconnection & Its Connection With Stoicism

“Do not wish that all things will go well with you, but that you will go well with all things.” 

– Epictetus, The Manual 

A man overlooking a rocky mountain landscape at the edge of a cliff to represent an article about amor fati in Stoicism

Amor fati without judgment 

A fundamental teaching of Stoicism is that the only thing that should be judged as good or bad is our character. To everything else, we apply a sort of indifference. Certain mindfulness meditation practices, too, teach us to discard labels of good or bad. Doing this leaves us with a neutrality that is open to embracing fate. 

Our imagination is masterful at painting all sorts of dark projections of this or that future outcome. Our brains evolved to assess risk and fear unfavorable outcomes, so value judgments are not something you can simply stop. But, we can temper them with mindful awareness, and say to ourselves ‘I don’t know if this outcome will be good or bad, but I’ll embrace it nonetheless.’ 

This requires some humility. We need the humility to admit that our first impressions about something’s good or bad nature may be totally wrong. There are almost always unexpected consequences and side effects. To try to plan and optimize for all these known unknowns is to drive yourself nuts. So bring a little flow to your life and begin practicing amor fati by questioning your judgments of good or bad. Plus, remember this powerful Stoic lesson: even if the outcome is objectively bad, you will find a way to use it to your advantage. 

Removing the self from the incident 

As you may have already noticed, I’ve turned to Epictetus’ writings to help inform this article from a Stoic perspective. For this next practical approach to amor fati, I’ll borrow from him directly: 

“When our neighbor’s boy breaks their window, we are likely to say, ‘Oh well, accidents happen.’ But how would you react if your own window was broken? You ought to react in the same way when it was your neighbor’s window that was broken.”

He goes on to say that we should do this even with less trivial things like the loss of a loved one. What he’s essentially saying here is that to take the blows that life lands on our chin, we must remove the attachment to the ego. The effect of this mental exercise of pretending it happened to the neighbor is just a means of removing the self from the equation. In Buddhism, too, we learn that over-attachment to the sense of self impedes much of our progress towards truly compassionate living. 

Let’s face it. The hard part of practicing amor fati is not the good stuff. It’s the losses and setbacks, both real and imagined, that are hard to swallow. But, one way of opening yourself to receive rather than reject life’s vicissitudes is by attempting to remove yourself from the equation altogether. 

Related article: No Self In Buddhism & Science: Tame The Ego, Start Living 

watch the pursuit of balance podcast now

Ignore the prognosticators 

The mind is perfectly capable of coming up with its own worries, so you don’t need other people feeding you theirs. People love to share their projections about the future. People make a living writing about the next existential threat. The news is borderline fear mongering. There is never a shortage of opinions on the next hot investment you don’t want to miss out on. 

Ignore it all as best you can. Turn off the news. Unfollow accounts on social media that don’t serve you in the present moment. Gently redirect the conversation when it turns to doomsday predictions. Ignore other people’s projections about the future because they influence you, whether you’d like to admit it or not. 

The cost of buying into other people’s fears or excitement about the future is that it can hinder your ability to venture off into the unknown. It creates doubt and hesitation in place of what should be your uninhibited sense of exploration and discovery. 

 

“When you hear predictions of the future, do not become fearful or excited. Remember that future events are beyond your control. […] Trust fate and trust yourself. Seek advice from the laws of nature, not prognosticators.”

– Epictetus, The Manual 

Amor fati of the unthinkable 

Most practitioners of Stoicism are familiar with the phrase memento mori, which translates to ‘remember your mortality’. In Buddhism, too, there are some highly-specific meditation protocols in which the meditator visualizes their death and decay. 

A lot of people struggle with this, including myself. For my own mortality, it just rarely crosses my mind. I’m normally too busy and engaged to think about it. The Stoics taught us to contemplate the finite nature of life not as a morbid, depressive exercise, but as a gentle slap in the face—a wakeup call. The purpose of contemplating memento mori is to jolt you back into the present moment, armed with renewed appreciation for life today. 

The Stoics urged us not to limit our contemplation of death to ourselves, either. They also wrote that we should contemplate the limited time we have with those we love most. 

If contemplating my own eventual death was hard, contemplating that of my immediate family is excruciating, so I’m not in a good position to recommend this as a practice. 

Don’t let fate catch you off guard

But, if I zoom out and examine this practice objectively—recognizing that our living-breathing connections will eventually be extinguished—it reminds me of another Stoic concept. Premeditatio malorum is the Stoic practice of considering future hardships so that we can prepare ourselves for them. If the primary purpose of memento mori practices is to foster gratitude for life here and now, then a secondary purpose may be preparing yourself for the eventual loss of your loved ones. 

I really don’t know if I agree personally with this last statement or not. Would my contemplation of losing my wife and child really lessen the unthinkable damage if it were to really happen? I think not. But, I can see how this contemplative practice would motivate me to be with them more fully—to close the laptop earlier than my ambition would like so that I can spend time with them. Finally, I can see how a person who goes through life consciously avoiding thoughts of death and loss would be more stricken by shock when death eventually comes knocking. 

Final thoughts 

I don’t want to end this piece on death, because amor fati is about life. Amor fati is about saying yes to life. It’s about feeling the fear and doing it anyway. The part of amor fati that most requires our attention and practice is embracing fear, doubt, loss, and negative emotions. But, we must do this because life is a two-sided coin. There is no joy without pain. There is no excitement without boredom, no growth without fear. 

To practice amor fati, we must begin to roll with the punches that life throws at us, because resisting against the forces of nature is a lost cause. We need to loosen our grip over and bring humility to our value judgments and ego. Ultimately, when I think of amor fati, I think of adventure. Good adventures don’t happen without the love of fate and the confidence that you’ll handle whatever that fate may be. 

Save 46% on Deep Work by Cal Newport

Debunking 8 Common Misconceptions About Stoicism: What It Really Means To Be A Stoic

I blame the English dictionary for a good chunk of the misconceptions about Stoicism. Look up the word ‘stoic’ there and you’ll find something like, “a person who can endure pain or hardship without showing their feelings or complaining.” Or maybe it’s the wealth of...

The Three Stoic Disciplines: Desire, Action, and Assent

Stoicism is a guiding framework in my life, but so is business. I can think of no better school of thought than business when it comes to manifesting ideas into reality—big, complex ideas. Schools of business and businesses in practice are fountains of knowledge when...

Improve Your Focus With Mindfulness- And Science-Based Protocols

I’ve said this before, but I feel it’s important to lead with it here: mindfulness is not a means to an end. Mindfulness is a means to a means—a way of waking up to life. Without mindfulness, so much of life escapes us. Without mindfulness, we’re governed by impulses...

What Is Modern Stoicism? An Introduction & Essential Practices

In the eyes of some, the people I’m about to introduce don’t belong in a discussion about modern Stoicism. None of them are self-proclaimed Stoics. But they do display extreme commitment to the four Stoic virtues: courage, temperance, wisdom, and justice.   ...

Where Buddhism And Modern Psychology Converge On Mental Wellness

When the average non-Buddhist westerner thinks of Buddhism, they often think of meditation, kindness, and monks with shaved heads in orange robes. But what lies beneath these surface-level artifacts is profound understanding. Few wisdom traditions have delivered as...

How To Speak Like A Stoic

If you’ve mastered the art of peaceful speech, then it is likely that you have a very firm grasp over your guiding principles. If you have mastered the art of the pause in speech, then it is likely that you have clear convictions and great self-confidence. Truthful,...

What The Death Of Marcus Aurelius Teaches Us About Life

Marcus Aurelius died in a cold, dark place, but his last words shined bright with a message of hope: “Go to the rising sun, for I am already setting.” He delivered these words not to a beloved, but to a guard of the night’s watch in his military camp near the...

Zen Meditation: How To Stop And Reflect For Wisdom 

  What if there was a way you could train your wisdom and insight? No tools or equipment required. No books to read. No classes to attend. All you’d need is a few minutes each day. Such a means of building a wider perspective and developing clear insight exists....

Memento Vivere: How To Live With Agency, Gratitude & Engagement

Antipater is a lesser-known Stoic, yet he was head of the school during a period that saw Stoicism extend to public life. Stoic philosophers were sent on diplomatic missions. Some advised kings. But Antipater’s contributions brought Stoicism closer to home. He was...

Right Mindfulness & Right Concentration Of The Eightfold Path

If I were to define Zen Buddhism, I would do so in two four-word sentences:   Absolute attention is prayer. Compassion for all beings.   “Zen teaches nothing. It merely enables us to wake up and become aware. It does not teach; it points. The truth of Zen is...

Spread the word and share the love 🙏

If you enjoyed this article, consider sharing it with your friends and followers on social media. Your support means the world to us. 💖 Click on the social share icons below and let others discover the insights, tips, and inspiration you found here. Together, we can create a community of like-minded individuals who practice mindfulness and Stoicism.

👉 Remember, a simple click can make a big difference!

Stoic Parenting: 6 Life Lessons From A New Father

Stoic Parenting: 6 Life Lessons From A New Father

Years ago, a good friend told me that having kids is the best way to renew your life. He had taken holidays in many different countries. He had eaten in loads of great restaurants. He was really good at his job. But, nothing was thrilling anymore. Experientially, he had plateaued. 

 

He explained that having a kid made everything feel new and exciting again. Suddenly, going to the beach was an adventure. Playing with toys was fun again. He remembered the value of stories. This renewed perspective was all possible because he was living vicariously, and in the present moment, through his son. This stuck with me as perhaps the greatest reason to have kids. 

 

The same friend also gave me the most convincing argument for not having kids: ‘Your life as you know it will be over,’ he warned me. 

 

I can now say that he was right about both things. At the time of writing, I’m still a very new dad. My first child was born only fifty days ago. It was, and is, the most joyful thing that’s ever happened to me. When I hold my son in my arms, the world stands still, and the only thing that matters is his health, happiness, and peace.

 

Being a new dad is also the most difficult thing I’ve ever done.

 

I’ve been practicing Stoicism seriously for about six years. The Stoics taught us to be grateful for life’s challenges, because if not for challenges, what’s the point of practicing philosophy in the first place? Plus, challenges serve as tests. The tough times tell us how far we’ve come in our practice and what we need to improve. 

 

6 Stoic parenting practices

 

I’ll share 6 Stoic parenting practices that have helped me immensely in early fatherhood. If you’re not a parent, I think you’ll still find that these Stoic parenting lessons apply to all kinds of life challenges.

 

This post contains affiliate links, which help us keep the blog afloat. Click here for more information.

A father carrying his son to represent an article about stoic parenting

There can only be one priority

 

When you think about it, the plural form of the word ‘priority’ is absurd. Priority means the most important thing. How can there be more than one most important thing? The answer is there can’t be. Having a child has made this abundantly clear for me. I still have goals, ambitions, and projects, but they do not conflict with my lone priority, which is my family. If I happen to find a quiet hour to myself for work, then that’s just a bonus. We would all benefit from clearly defining that one most important thing in our lives.

The pursuit of balance podcast year end sale, save 60%

Anticipate that things will go wrong

 

Negative visualization, also known by the Latin phrase premeditatio malorum, is a concept in Stoicism that teaches us to look around corners for what could go wrong. In business, they would call this risk assessment and mitigation. The mitigation is the point here. We don’t imagine what could go wrong as some morbid exercise to train up our anxiety. Rather, we do it to promote preparedness. 

 

When we enter into a difficult situation knowing that certain things may go wrong, two things happen. First, we may be able to prevent those bad things from happening. Then, if they do happen, we won’t be taken by surprise. 

 

I’ve been applying this lately by understanding that the baby will likely cry at the very moment I’m about to fall into much needed sleep. I know to be ready with contingency diapers at all times. On a more serious level, I know exactly which numbers to call and where to go if my son gets sick or if there’s an emergency.

 

Related article: Premeditatio Malorum: A Practice For Resilience 

 

Stoic parenting: You need to be the example

 

Although my son is still an infant, it’s already clear that he’s observing me. He’s absorbing my every move. 

 

Epictetus said, “Don’t explain your philosophy. Embody it.” 

 

Despite the lack of sleep and free time, I’m still making an immense effort to exercise. I still find time to meditate—even if for just five minutes. It’s imperative that I cook healthy meals for my wife and myself. I cannot lose any ground on being a strong, healthy person, because I need to be one for my son. I need to be the example for him. Stoic parenting means exemplifying the behaviours you want to instill in your children.

A father holding his son to represent an article about stoic parenting

Stoic parenting and the love of fate

 

Amor fati is another Latin phrase that comes up in Stoic literature. It means ‘the love of fate.’ The operative word here is ‘love’. It’s not a begrudging acceptance, but an enthusiastic embrace of the unknown—of the uncontrollable and the wondrous. 

 

Having a baby has re-emphasized this for me because making plans has become nearly impossible. As a fairly structured, organized person, this has been a hard adjustment for me. But, I’m learning to go with the flow and accept that the day will unfold the way it’s meant to unfold. As long as I’m taking care of my single priority, the order in which events unfold is not important. 

 

Being a new dad has also forced me to embrace the unknown on really important matters. Where are we going to live in five years? How will we pay for this or that? How are we going to visit the grandparents (given that we’re all living on three different continents)? I don’t know the answers to these questions. I don’t want to know the answers. I will focus on the process, remain in the present moment as much as possible, and will gladly welcome the various twists and turns of life. 

Related article: How To Practice Amor Fati

 

Keep your eyes on the ship

 

One of my favorite passages from Epictetus’ The Manual is one where he describes sailors going ashore on a break from their duties. Epictetus says that the men should enjoy searching for beautiful seashells and strolling leisurely on the beach, but only if they keep the ship within their view. The ship may call them back at any moment, so they should be ready at all times. 

 

This teaches us to enjoy our times of rest. We can and should indulge in activities that don’t have a desired outcome. The key is to be ready to be called upon. Also, we can take refuge in the understanding that we’re resting so we can be better when duty calls. 

watch the pursuit of balance podcast now

Have fewer desires

 

Aside from the lack of sleep, taking care of an infant or child is not actually that difficult. You just need a little mindful awareness and a lot of love. It’s not particularly complicated or strenuous. It gets stressful when you’d rather be doing something else. Soothing a crying baby can be a wonderful exercise in compassion when your singular focus is to soothe the baby. However, taking care of a crying baby when you’d rather be sleeping, eating, or working, is when things get stressful. 

 

Stoicism and Buddhism both emphasize the need to reduce our desires. The fewer conditions that you require to be happy, the more easily and often you will find happiness. 

 

“The faculty of desire purports to aim at securing what you want… If you fail in your desire, you are unfortunate, if you experience what you would rather avoid, you are unhappy… For desire, suspend it completely for now.” 

– Epictetus 

 

Related article: Desirelessness Is Happiness: 7 Practices To Stop Grasping

Final thoughts

 

My friend was right. The life I was living before having a child is effectively over. But, with change comes freshness. Once we have the tools and practices to navigate change, we can see the good in it. Sure, change means uncertainty, anxiety, and looking like a fool at times. But, change also means growth. It means evolution. 

 

Stoicism helps us develop the moral character required to live in accordance with our values and virtues. This is true for both our routines and the inevitable twists life throws at us. This has been an article about my early reflections on Stoic parenting, but really, the lessons I’ve shared are about dealing with the ebbs and flows of life. 

Introduction To Stoicism And Mindfulness

If you're new to mindfulness or Stoicism, we hope you'll find these articles written as introductory resources useful. We aim to answer questions like "What is mindfulness?" and "How can I begin practicing Stoicism?" We hope something here will set you off on your...

Improve Your Focus With Mindfulness- And Science-Based Protocols

I’ve said this before, but I feel it’s important to lead with it here: mindfulness is not a means to an end. Mindfulness is a means to a means—a way of waking up to life. Without mindfulness, so much of life escapes us. Without mindfulness, we’re governed by impulses...

Where Buddhism And Modern Psychology Converge On Mental Wellness

When the average non-Buddhist westerner thinks of Buddhism, they often think of meditation, kindness, and monks with shaved heads in orange robes. But what lies beneath these surface-level artifacts is profound understanding. Few wisdom traditions have delivered as...

Karma In Buddhism: Sowing The Seeds Of Love

In modern times, we use the word karma in many ways. ‘Ain’t karma a bitch’—meaning what ‘Goes around, comes around.’ It can also refer to the Golden Rule from the Hebrew and Christian Bible: ‘Do unto others what as you would have them do unto you.’ But, in the context...

What The Death Of Marcus Aurelius Teaches Us About Life

Marcus Aurelius died in a cold, dark place, but his last words shined bright with a message of hope: “Go to the rising sun, for I am already setting.” He delivered these words not to a beloved, but to a guard of the night’s watch in his military camp near the...

Zen Meditation: How To Stop And Reflect For Wisdom 

  What if there was a way you could train your wisdom and insight? No tools or equipment required. No books to read. No classes to attend. All you’d need is a few minutes each day. Such a means of building a wider perspective and developing clear insight exists....

Right Mindfulness & Right Concentration Of The Eightfold Path

If I were to define Zen Buddhism, I would do so in two four-word sentences:   Absolute attention is prayer. Compassion for all beings.   “Zen teaches nothing. It merely enables us to wake up and become aware. It does not teach; it points. The truth of Zen is...

The Three Jewels Of The Tao: Embracing The Way Of Water

Well, the first challenge in understanding the Tao is its definition. Translated literally, 'The Tao' means 'The Way'. The very first verse of this ancient teaching warns that it’s useless to try to define or name The Tao: The Tao that can be toldIs not the eternal...

21 Human Performance Tips For Busy People

To say my life is busy is an understatement. Writing this blog is my passion. I wouldn’t trade it for the world. But writing the blog, two weekly newsletters, and a book is a tall order. There is no team, there are no editors, web developers, graphic designers, or...

Thich Nhat Hanh & The Zen Practice Of Stopping

Thich Nhat Hanh was a Vietnamese Zen Buddhist monk, peace activist, prolific author, poet and teacher, historically known as the ‘father of mindfulness’. Nhat Hanh was a major influence on Western practices of Buddhism.   He was exiled from South Vietnam in 1966 after...
Ataraxia: How Stoics Achieve Equanimity

Ataraxia: How Stoics Achieve Equanimity

Let’s paint a picture. Imagine drops of water landing on a lotus leaf and sliding down and off. The drop doesn’t linger. It makes its impact and then flows with gravity until it is gone. The lotus leaf is aware of the drop—it feels it—but it does not reject, retain, or struggle. It is undisturbed. This is a picture of the Stoic concept of ataraxia.

 

Just like the lotus leaf, we all have the capacity to let negative reactions and excessive desire roll off our backs. 

 

In this article, we’ll provide a definition of ataraxia as it relates to Stoicism and share practices for achieving ataraxia by breaking it down to its core components: composure, steadiness, ego, and quietude. 

This post contains affiliate links, which help us keep the blog afloat. Click here for more information.

Drop of water on a lotus leaf to represent ataraxia

What is ataraxia?

 

Ataraxia in Stoicism and other Hellenistic philosophies such as Epicureanism is a state of composure characterized by lack of distress and outward displays of strong emotion, especially in difficult situations. Essentially, ataraxia is equanimity.

 

Achieving ataraxia was never the primary objective of Stoicism. That coveted pinnacle is to live in accordance with nature through developing strong moral character. Ataraxia was seen as a by-product of one’s pursuit of moral character. 

 

Imperturbability is another word that’s closely related to ataraxia. More simply, ataraxia is a state of non-reaction. It is not a denial of feelings. We feel what the world throws at us, both the good and the bad, but we don’t react or at least don’t overreact. Ataraxia is commonly associated with calm, but calm is just how ataraxia appears to the observer. With ataraxia, we let go of troubles, sadness, or anger quickly and calmly. So ataraxia means that we feel the ups and downs of life, we can get upset, we can have plans and preferences, but we let go of charged emotions or intense cravings in a timely manner.

 

How Stoics achieve ataraxia 

 

In his book, Stillness Is The Key, Ryan Holiday speaks of what it means to achieve ataraxia: 

 

“To be steady while the world spins around you. To act without frenzy. To hear only what needs to be heard. To possess quietude—exterior and interior—on command.” 

 

If we were to break this definition of ataraxia down to its most fundamental components, we’d be left with a useful framework for achieving ataraxia in our own lives. These components are composure, steadiness, ego, and quietude.

The pursuit of balance podcast year end sale, save 60%

Composure as a component of ataraxia

 

To be composed amid chaos is to be grounded. Think of a pebble tossed into a raging river. Engulfed in the force of rushing water, it sinks effortlessly to its destination where it will remain still as the water flows overhead. 

 

To build the habit of composed behavior in stressful situations, the first practical step is to stop. The next time you find yourself being swept along by emotions or events, simply pause. All it takes to drastically change your response is five seconds during which you do nothing but breathe.

 

Then, after you’ve mastered the ability to pause, which ultimately reminds you of your intention to handle the situation with composure and provides a more relaxed physiological response, you can begin to leverage other practices of Stoicism to help you navigate the complexity. You can practice negative visualization to anticipate and mitigate risk. You can use The Dichotomy of Control to identify what is within and what is outside of your control. Find guidance by recalling the Four Stoic Virtues

 

The first step to practice is the pause. 

 

Steadiness as a component of ataraxia

 

It’s not sexy advice, but to practice steadiness and to ultimately cultivate ataraxia is to slow down. Doing anything even just five percent slower makes your actions more deliberate and precise. Start practicing this with simple things like preparing a meal. Once your default state is a little bit slower, you’ll speak with more purpose in meetings, your writing will be clearer, and you’ll be more caring with those you love. 

 

Another aspect of steadiness is consistency. Whether it’s your desire to achieve ataraxia or your Stoicism practice in general, you will falter at times. You will have lazy and undisciplined moments. You will make mistakes. The key is to reset yourself on the path as quickly as possible. Keep the intervals between lapses in discipline as short as possible, and show up for yourself every day.

Drop of water on a lotus leaf as a visual representation of ataraxia

Ego as a component of ataraxia

 

I read a lot about Buddhism, and in no small part because I’m motivated to learn more about the concept of non-self. There are even science-based arguments that suggest that our concept of self is often unreliable, false, and largely repetitive. 

 

Non-self is very difficult to grasp and it takes a lot of practice. But, we can take some steps towards healthier levels of attachment to the concept of ‘me’. 

 

First, we need to acknowledge that our sense of self is composed of beliefs. These beliefs are fluid and constantly changing. So, when someone insults or criticizes me, I shouldn’t feel that it’s an attack on the entirety of my being. At most, it’s just someone’s belief that opposes a belief I hold about myself. When someone calls you lazy, don’t feel injured at the level of your whole self. It’s nothing more than a challenge to your belief about your work-ethic. 

 

Another aspect of imperturbability of the ego is believing that you are whole. There is nothing anyone could add to your existence that would make it better or worse. There is nothing anyone could subtract from your existence that would make it better or worse. Be at peace with yourself. Love yourself. Don’t rely on external conditions to be happy.

 

Quietude as a component of ataraxia

 

The most practical way to develop ataraxia is to focus on your thoughts and your speech. 

 

There’s a lot of debate on the validity of certain claims about how neuro linguistic programming can positively affect mood and behavior. Basically, some say that the more positive your self-talk is, the better you’ll feel and behave. 

 

Intuitively, I can see how this could be true. Also, I can’t see a downside to attempting to foster positive thoughts in place of negative ones. Be confident in your self-talk. Don’t beat yourself up over mistakes. Try to observe how repetitive your negative self-talk is. The mind likes to play the hits. In a way, this means that negative self-talk—all that doubting, self-limiting, and worrying internal banter—is quite boring and meaningless. Try to plant the seeds of positivity with your thoughts. 

 

With our speech, we can embrace frugality and purpose. It’s OK to be the quietest person in the room. Saying less leaves more room for listening. You can learn so much more from listening than by speaking. In heated interpersonal matters, practice the pause we spoke about earlier. Take a moment to recall your intention. Is your ultimate goal in this situation to make a point? Or is your goal to maintain a healthy relationship? If it’s someone you care about, I suspect it’s the latter, so maybe don’t make that point—don’t be right. Instead, let your speech reflect empathy and promote reconciliation. 

watch the pursuit of balance podcast now

Final thoughts 

 

When we hear a concept with a Greek name like ataraxia, it can seem a bit foreign and irrelevant. But, when we define the concept and break it down into smaller, actionable components, it becomes easier to grasp. Ataraxia is equanimity, imperturbability, and being unshakable. Resilience is part of it, too, because Stoics are not robots. We have emotions, desires, and preferences, but we strive to harmonize our speech and actions with our values. This means pausing to think. Then, when we do act or speak, we use forethought and deliberation. Finally, we are not so easily hurt by the words of others because we are not inflexibly attached to the notion of self. 

Introduction To Stoicism And Mindfulness

If you're new to mindfulness or Stoicism, we hope you'll find these articles written as introductory resources useful. We aim to answer questions like "What is mindfulness?" and "How can I begin practicing Stoicism?" We hope something here will set you off on your...

Improve Your Focus With Mindfulness- And Science-Based Protocols

I’ve said this before, but I feel it’s important to lead with it here: mindfulness is not a means to an end. Mindfulness is a means to a means—a way of waking up to life. Without mindfulness, so much of life escapes us. Without mindfulness, we’re governed by impulses...

Where Buddhism And Modern Psychology Converge On Mental Wellness

When the average non-Buddhist westerner thinks of Buddhism, they often think of meditation, kindness, and monks with shaved heads in orange robes. But what lies beneath these surface-level artifacts is profound understanding. Few wisdom traditions have delivered as...

Karma In Buddhism: Sowing The Seeds Of Love

In modern times, we use the word karma in many ways. ‘Ain’t karma a bitch’—meaning what ‘Goes around, comes around.’ It can also refer to the Golden Rule from the Hebrew and Christian Bible: ‘Do unto others what as you would have them do unto you.’ But, in the context...

What The Death Of Marcus Aurelius Teaches Us About Life

Marcus Aurelius died in a cold, dark place, but his last words shined bright with a message of hope: “Go to the rising sun, for I am already setting.” He delivered these words not to a beloved, but to a guard of the night’s watch in his military camp near the...

Zen Meditation: How To Stop And Reflect For Wisdom 

  What if there was a way you could train your wisdom and insight? No tools or equipment required. No books to read. No classes to attend. All you’d need is a few minutes each day. Such a means of building a wider perspective and developing clear insight exists....

Right Mindfulness & Right Concentration Of The Eightfold Path

If I were to define Zen Buddhism, I would do so in two four-word sentences:   Absolute attention is prayer. Compassion for all beings.   “Zen teaches nothing. It merely enables us to wake up and become aware. It does not teach; it points. The truth of Zen is...

The Three Jewels Of The Tao: Embracing The Way Of Water

Well, the first challenge in understanding the Tao is its definition. Translated literally, 'The Tao' means 'The Way'. The very first verse of this ancient teaching warns that it’s useless to try to define or name The Tao: The Tao that can be toldIs not the eternal...

21 Human Performance Tips For Busy People

To say my life is busy is an understatement. Writing this blog is my passion. I wouldn’t trade it for the world. But writing the blog, two weekly newsletters, and a book is a tall order. There is no team, there are no editors, web developers, graphic designers, or...

Thich Nhat Hanh & The Zen Practice Of Stopping

Thich Nhat Hanh was a Vietnamese Zen Buddhist monk, peace activist, prolific author, poet and teacher, historically known as the ‘father of mindfulness’. Nhat Hanh was a major influence on Western practices of Buddhism.   He was exiled from South Vietnam in 1966 after...

Spread the word and share the love 🙏

If you enjoyed this article, consider sharing it with your friends and followers on social media. Your support means the world to us. 💖 Click on the social share icons below and let others discover the insights, tips, and inspiration you found here. Together, we can create a community of like-minded individuals who practice mindfulness and Stoicism.

👉 Remember, a simple click can make a big difference!